Table 2-1 Examples of commercial heat-resistant alloys including rare earth elements
                                      mass%
Fe Ni Co Cr Al C RE Others
Alloy 556(UNS R30556) bal. 20 18 22 0.2 0.1 La=0.02 Mo=3, W=2.5, Ta
Alloy 230(UNS N06230) 3 bal. 5 22 0.1 La=0.02 W=14
Alloy 214(UNS N07214) 3 bal. 5 16 4.5 0.05 Y=0.01 Zr, B
Alloy 188(UNS R30188) 3 22 bal. 22 0.1 La=0.03 W=14
Table 2-2 Coatings for high-temperature corrosion protection (revised referring to references 21 to 23)
Method Coating material Advantages Disadvantages
Diffusion coating
(Pack cementation, Slurry coating)
Cr, Al, Si, Cr-Al, Cr-Si, Al-Si, etc. ・Since a diffusion layer is formed providing good adhesion to the alloy substrate, the coating is hard to separate from the material. ・Processable elements are limited.
・Controlling the film thickness and concentration is difficult.
・Since the entire base material is processed in a furnace,a large-sized furnace is required depending on the size of the material to be processed, and a problem such as the deformation of the processed material may arise.
Thermal spraying MCrAlX (M:Co, Ni, Fe X: Y, Hf, Zr, etc.), Ni-Cr, Ni-Cr-Al, etc., ceramics ・Various types of alloy and ceramic films can be formed.
・The film formation rate is high.
・The film is porous.
・Depending on the thermal spraying method, the film adhesion may not be good, resulting in the separation of the film.
Note: A self-fluxing alloy may be used to obtain a dense film.
Overlay welding Ni-, Co-, Fe-based heat-resistant alloys, etc. ・A thick film can be formed.
・A minute film with fewer pores can be formed.
・A film with good adhesion can be formed.
・Because of the large heat input, preheating or postheating treatment may be required to prevent the deformation or hardening of the alloy substrate.
・A thin film is hard to form.
Electron beam physical vapor deposition (EBPVD) Ceramics (Thermal barrier coating like YSZ) ・Even ceramics whose melting point is close to 3 000 ℃ are capable of vapor deposition.
・The structure can be controlled in a nano-order.
・The film growth is much faster than that of conventional vapordeposition methods.
・Because of its columnar structure, the film has good thermal shock resistance.
・Since the equipment is extremely expensive, this method is not suitable for general industrial products with low added-value. This method is applied only to high addedvalue products such as jet engines.
・Because of its columnar structure, the film’s thermal barrier performance is inferior to that of the film formed by thermal spraying.
Combined treatment (plating + diffusion coating, or thermal spraying + diffusion coating) Pt plating + Al diffusion coating, or NiCr thermal spraying + Al diffusion coating ・Additional diffusion coating can compensate for the disadvantages of each coating method, providing new functions. ・Due to a two-step process, more work time is required.
Table 2-3 Features of thermal spraying coatings (revised referring to reference 28)
Heat source Method Particle velocity Heat source temperature Thermal spray materials Adhesive strength (MPa) Porosity(%) Features
Gas type Flame spraying Relatively slow
(around 200 m/s)
Relatively low
(around 2000 ℃)
Metals, oxides 20 to 40 10 to 20 ・A film is formed by thermal spraying with compressed air of the thermal spray particle produced by melting the thermal spray material continuously supplied to the combustion flame whose heat sources are oxygen and acetylene.
High velocity oxy fuel spraying (HVOF) Fast
(around 700 m/s)
Relatively low
(around 2000 ℃)
Metals, cermet Not less than 70 1 to 5 ・Since the thermal spray particles collide with the base material surface at a speed exceeding the speed of sound, a highly adhesive and dense film is formed.
Electric type Arc spraying Middle
(around 300 m/s)
Middle to relatively high
(around 5000 ℃)
Metals 20 to 40 10 to 20 ・Arc discharge between two metal wires generates discharge energy that melts the wires.
・The volume of the film formed by thermal spraying per unit time is large.
・The thermal spray materials are limited to materials with electrical conductivity.
Atmospheric plasma spraying Relatively fast
(around 500 m/s)
High
(5000 to 10000 ℃)
Metals, ceramics, cermet 20 to 70 1 to 20 ・In a gas such as Ar, arc discharge generates a high-temperature, high-speed plasma jet to melt the thermal spray material and accelerate the spray speed.
・Thermal spraying can be used for almost all materials including metals, cermet, and ceramics with a high melting point.
Low pressure plasma spraying Relatively fast
(around 500 m/s)
High
(5000 to 10000 ℃)
Metals, ceramics, cermet Not less than 70 1 to 5 ・Since this process is performed in a chamber in which the atmosphere is controlled by purging inert gas under reduced pressure, the characteristics of the thermal spray material cannot be impaired.
・A film can be formed on active metals such as Ti.
・The film adhesion is good.